Book & Media Reviews (Archives)
- Life After Loss: Conquering Grief and Finding Hope, by Raymond Moody Jr., M.D., and Dianne Arcangel
- Mourning Has Broken- A Collection Of Creative Writing about Grief and Healing, Foreword by Alan Wolfelt, Ph.D.
- The Moon Came Down on Milk Street, by Jean Gralley
- Brick Lane, by Monica Ali
- Making Loss Matter: Creating Meaning in Difficult Times, by Rabbi David Wolpe
- The Life and Death of Charlie St.Cloud, by Ben Sherwood
- Searching for a Mustard Seed, by Miriam Sagan
- Grief Denied: A Vietnam Widow's Story, reprinted with permission from Pauline Laurent
- Terrorism: The Only Way is Through, by Rosina G. Schnurr, Ph.D.
- My Father's Ghost: the Return of My Old Man and Other Second Chances, by Suzy McKee Charnas
- Flash of Life, by Kara L.C. Jones
- Treasures of Darkness, by Ken Hekman
- Book Announcement: Beyond Coping-Widows Reinventing Their Lives, collected by Molly Hurd and Margie Macdonald
- Waking to Tears: Losing a Loved One to Violence, compiled by Traci Bieber Nelson
- A World of Widows, by Margaret Owen
- Healing Grief: Reclaiming Life after any Loss, James Van Praagh
Books are one of the best places to find the information and support you are seeking to help you cope with your grief and begin to rebuild your life.
If you decide to order one of the books listed here in the Book Review Section, please consider doing it through the Grief and Renewal link to Amazon.Com. By going directly from the book on this site to the book on Amazon's site and ordering you will also be helping to support Grief and Renewal.com.
Our goal is to be able to generate funds to donate to Empowering Women in
Development and thus reach out in hope and caring toward others whose loss is
even more devastating than our own. Thank you!
Life After Loss: Conquering Grief and Finding Hope
by Raymond Moody Jr., M.D., and Dianne Arcangel
HarperCollins Publishers Inc., New York, NY 2001
ISBN: 0-06-251729-5
pp. 228
Reviewed by: Sarah Tuttle, 12-5-2005
[Order from Amazon.com]
In their book, Life After Loss: Conquering Grief and Finding Hope, Dr. Moody and Dianne Arcangel present a text devoted to the explanation of grief. Their topics range from grief’s causes and effects to different methods of dealing with the loss of a loved one. For anyone looking for a straightforward and faith-based read to help ground them in the basics of grief, this book will prove a very useful resource.
Life After Loss: Conquering Grief and Finding Hope offers one main theme: no one is immune to emotion. Those feeling alone in their grief may find solace in this message, as well as in the author’s clear recognition of the individualized process of grief. Some excellent advice can also be found in these pages for those who do not know how to aid those around them who are coping with grief.
For those overwhelmed by the emotions of grief wrap this book provides very clear examples of how to identify the signs of grief, and warns against the dangers of not dealing with this powerful emotion in a healthy way. Although the authors throughout the book emphasize therapy as the most effective way to deal with grief, they offer other resources as well. One of the assets of this book is the thirty-six page compilation of works and organizations specifically geared towards coping with grief. A large portion of these resources are categorized by the cause of grief. For instance, an individual suffering from the loss of a child could turn to this section of the book, and immediately find a list of over fifty resources geared specifically towards this subject.
However, some readers may also find themselves frustrated by the tone in which the authors write. The authors’ selection of phrasing and presentation feels over-simplified, as though they doubt the reader’s ability to truly comprehend the subject at hand. Topics are not explored in depth; rather a brief definition or description, usually not more than one paragraph in lengh, precedes a reality-based story that deals with the subject discussed. While these stories help the reader to relate to the topic at hand, they too would benefit from more detail.
Nevertheless, the direct style of the authors may be refreshing, since the reader does not have to wade through heavy medical terms to understand the meaning of the text. For an individual just beginning their quest to resolve or cope with grief, this book is an excellent springboard off of which to embark upon further research.
return to top
KOPE Associates:
Mourning Has Broken - A Collection Of Creative Writing about Grief and Healing
Foreword by Alan Wolfelt, Ph.D.
Reviewed by Cynthia Gasner
Anthology about Grief and Healing
By CYNTHIA GASNER
Special to The CJN
Mara Koven and Liz Pearl | Mara Koven was mourning the sudden death of her 39-year-old husband and Liz Pearl was grieving the loss of her maternal grandmother when they decided to harness their pain in a creative way.
At a kickboxing class, Pearl approached Koven and said, "I know you must be going through hell, but I think I have an exciting project for us to work on that may be worthwhile."
From there, Pearl recounts, they went on to co-edit and publish Mourning Has Broken – A Collection of Creative Writing about Grief and Healing.
The anthology contains 50 original submissions about healing from the pain of losing a loved one. The writers share their thoughts and make the reader cry and laugh, but they always express their inner strength and insights about coping.
Pearl, who specializes in psychogeriatrics, expressive art therapies and adult education, says that she and Koven "firmly believe that creative writing can be an expressive and therapeutic medium of healing from grief."
The book includes submissions from Canada, Australia, Costa Rica, Holland, Israel and the United States. The authors, Pearl says, are mothers, fathers, wives, husbands, siblings, children, friends and caring citizens.
The book also includes a range of writing forms, including narrative, poetry, song, prayer, letters, lists, journal entries, eulogies and obituaries.
"Bereavement is inevitable to the human experience, so the creative healing process is potentially universal," says Koven, a writer whose post-graduate studies were in journalism and Jewish communal studies.
"Many of the people who submitted their works said, 'Even if you don't publish my work, I am eternally grateful for the opportunity to have participated in this valuable process.'"
Pearl adds, "We were able to learn from the grief of the authors, who bring support and solace to others. And although we're based in Toronto, we succeeded in reaching out to many internationally renowned bereavement professionals, including Rabbi Dr. Earl Grollman, Reverend Dr. Richard Gilbert and Dr. Darcie Sims."
Longtime grief counselor and educator Dr. Alan Wolfelt of Fort Collins, Colo., who wrote the forward to Mourning Has Broken, notes that story-writing and storytelling help the healing process.
"Tell the story of the death and you begin to acknowledge it," he writes. "Tell it 10 times and you begin to let it enter your heart. Tell it over and over and you find it becoming part of who you are."
Elsewhere in the book, Dr. Edward Pakes, a psychiatrist in Toronto who has worked with many bereaved individuals, defines mourning as "the active, deliberate process of digesting the indigestible grief after bereavement."
Pakes writes that he hopes readers will be partially healed by reading what contributors have written about their own experiences.
KOPE Associates – "KOPE" being a play on the word "cope" that's incorporates the first two letters of "Koven" and "Pearl" – has published a limited first edition of Mourning Has Broken, which is available at several local book stores, including Caversham Booksellers, Parent Books, Israel's and Negev Importing.
Pearl and Koven are currently completing the research and editorial work for their next collaboration, a collection of original writing by stroke survivors. The book will be released in June.
For more information on Mourning Has Broken or the new anthology, e-mail lizpearl@sympatico.ca.
return to top
The Moon Came Down on Milk Street
Written and Illustrated by Jean Gralley
Henry Holt and Company, New York 2004
Reviewed by: Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D.
In a time of natural disasters, wars, and security alerts parents might well wonder how to talk to their young children about the scary things they see and hear on the news. The Moon Came Down on Milk Street is a wonderfully illustrated picture book which will help. Jean Gralley who has studied children’s books and illustration with Maurice Sendak, has created a wonderful book which gives the reassuring message to children that we all help each other through bad times and that the adult world can fix things and make the world a safer place.
The story begins with a special TV report: the moon is slipping out of the night sky. We see it lightly skimming the tops of tall buildings, slipping past windows, and resting in pieces on a city’s streets. The story asks, “Who will make this right again?” Helpers of all kinds come from every corner, each answering, “We will!” The child reader will relate to the helpers who are illustrated as children thereby providing an empowering message which states that there are adults who will help but that children can be helpers too. This provides children with a sense of control as well as security. The illustrations depict a festival of cooperative activities: roping, pulling, gluing, and hoisting as fire fighters, doctors, nurses, police, rescue workers, and even helper dogs join in the effort to restore the moon to its rightful place in the night sky.
The soothing ending in which the tired helpers are “good-nighted” one by one, will help the worried or concerned child to feel ready to slip into dream time as the story ends.
In these scary times the fear of something bad and terrible happening to family, friends and country lurks just beneath the surface of our daily lives. Children also suffer these fears, although they may not state them explicitly. Often signs of their concerns can be found in their play, drawings, sleep patterns and other behaviors such as excessive clinging to a care giver or aggressive acting out. It is important for the adult world to be aware of and respond to the unvoiced but realistic concerns of the children. One way of helping children is to acknowledge the realities they are responding to but to shift their attention from what could go wrong to the many people who help when something does go wrong. This “we can do it” message helps to shift fear to optimism.
The illustrations in The Moon Came Down On Milk Street are colorful, comforting, witty and appealing. This is the kind of book that a young child will enjoy reading again and again!
return to top
Brick Lane
by Monica Ali
Scribner
New York, New York
2003 (Double Day) pp.415
Reviewed by: Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D.
Brick Lane by Monica Ali is recommended here as a book that describes the lives of two women as they come to terms with the contradictions of cultural and religious expectations and their own strivings for personhood. In this wonderfully written and award winning novel we follow the lives of two Bangladeshi sisters whose response to arranged marriage leads them down different paths.
When their father arranges marriages for the two sisters, Hasina disobeys, runs away with her lover, and marries him. Nazneen bows to tradition and is flown to London where she is married to a much older man and lives on an ‘estate’ for immigrants. The novel parallels their lives and provides a remarkable contrapuntal portrait of the psychological and economic struggle for selfhood both women face. Hasina's life takes a harsh turn when her husband becomes abusive and she runs away, thus becoming a single woman in a country where there is little protection for single women. The plight of widows and women who are not wanted in the families they have married into is panoramically portrayed in Hasina's letters to her sister in London.
Nazneen's ostensibly more traditional journey as she fulfills the duties of mother and wife, takes some unexpected turns as she comes to find her inner world and the larger world that exists both outside of herself and the estate. Through Nazneen the reader is shown the process of self-discovery of a person who has been taught that they have no choice in their life but to obey family, husband, God. Through Hasina the reader shares external discoveries about the place of women in the Bangladeshi social order and the lack of legal protection and justice that exists for women there and in similar cultures.
In providing this double image of the sisters' development Ali creates a complex and complete vision of the status of women in developing countries and where their quest for self-hood may eventually take them. Brick Lane is richly painted and is rewarding on many levels. Once engaged in the lives of these remarkable women, the reader will not want to stop reading until the end, and even then will be reluctant to put the book aside.
return to top
Making Loss Matter: Creating Meaning in Difficult Times
by Rabbi David Wolpe
Riverhead Books, 1999, 221 pp.
Reviewed by Kimberly Ross Largey
7.9.2004
Making Loss Matter: Creating Meaning in Difficult Times is a book that readers will find useful in more than one situation. The author, Rabbi David Wolpe, draws from personal experience, biblical stories, western philosophy and literature to lay out a road map for the reader which will help them navigate and survive the difficult path of personal loss. Whether it be the loss of dreams, faith, home, love or life, Rabbi Wolpe urges us to embrace the stinging pain of loss (in all its forms) and seek out the meaning which hurt can bring.
This final version of Wolpe's book came about after his wife, Ellie, was diagnosed with cancer. He admits that he felt his "life was suddenly full of shadows", as he faced the possibility of a life raising his daughter alone. Ellie did survive, but in the end her illness helped the Rabbi to realize that life's inevitable downs and losses must be faced with courage and love - only then can the strength and hope rise from the soul of the pain.
This is just one example that Rabbi Wolpe uses to illustrate his ideas on the difficult concept of what loss means. He further investigates how the loss of dreams and faith can be just as frightening and disconcerting as experiencing the loss of a loved one, a home (emotionally and literally), or loss of self. This book encourages its readers not to turn their backs on loss but embrace it. Making Loss Matter will appeal to people of all faiths, as well as those curious about what it means to live a full life while being conscious of all the things that come with it.
return to top
The Life and Death of Charlie St.Cloud
by Ben Sherwood
Bantam Books
New York, New York, 277pp.
Reviewed by Kimberly Ross Largey
5.3.2004
There are countless questions about what happens to us after we die. Is there a heaven? What does it look like, feel like, sound like? Are we re-incarnated? Can we do the same things we did on Earth? Can I still eat my favorite coconut ice cream there? Well, if I were a character in Ben Sherwood’s The Life and Death of Charlie St.Cloud I might. This is a work of fiction that combines many of the ideas on life after death we’ve heard about for ages, but Ben Sherwood focuses less on the great beyond and more on what the dead can teach us about living.
Charlie St.Cloud is a man who should be in his prime; an attractive, twenty-something, with a good heart and great intelligence .The novel begins where Charlie’s life was put on hold-- the tragic death of his younger brother Sam. Strongly bonded by their love of the Red Sox, Charlie and Sam were returning home from a game in Boston when they are hit by a drunk driver. Charlie should have been dead, but was spared at the last second, trapping him between the living and the spirit worlds. This is what makes Charlie special—this experience has left him with the ability to communicate and see the recently deceased. It also allows him to hold onto Sam forever if he chooses. Charlie’s unfettered dedication to Sam puts his life in limbo. He takes a job at the local cemetery to remain close to him, never straying far for fear that Sam will disappear forever. This is also where Charlie’s work as a liaison to the other side comes into play given that he can see and interact with both the dead and the living.
It isn’t until Charlie meets Tess, the local untamed beauty who is training for her first solo sailing race around the world, that he is shaken out of the isolated world he has created for himself and for Sam.
By transcending the normal boundaries separating life and death, this story tells its readers that life is ultimately about choosing present love of what and whom you have over living in a past that you can never retrieve. This story’s heart-warming characters pull you into their struggles and uplift our hearts in the end.
Publishers Note: I walked into a book store in Edgartown on Martha’s Vineyard on Memorial Day weekend and saw The Life and Death of Charlie St. Cloud prominently displayed this book, with a fond note highly recommending it written by one of the staff.
return to top
Searching for a Mustard Seed
By Miriam Sagan
Quality Words in Print
Costa Mesa, California 2003, 207 pp.
Reviewed by Kimberly Ross Largey
4.11.2004
In the beginning of Miriam Sagan's memoir, Searching for a Mustard Seed: One Young Widow's Unconventional Story, she tells the story of her life and marriage to a dying man. Struggling with Colitis her husband Robert, a Zen priest, slowly declines in the quiet of their Santa Fe home while Miriam's own struggle to keep her family and her sanity together swirl around the nebula of his terrible illness and deteriorating condition. As the disease takes over his body, Miriam becomes the sole provider for Robert and their young daughter Isabel, leaving her little time to care for herself and to deal with the pain, loss and frustration that she confronts everyday during this difficult period.
It is not until after Roberts's death that she has the time or state of mind to construct a narrative of her own and come to realize how her life has changed. In the introduction to her book she tells the reader about her search for literature that would aid in making sense of her experiences, but surprisingly she found very little. She states:
"I wrote this book to tell my story. I wrote it because my contemporaries will not live forever and because grief is either a path we have trod or will have trod. I wrote it so that some woman like me might find a friendlier book on the shelf."
Her story is honest. It doesn't sugar coat her thoughts, feelings or experiences on her marriage, her husband or her situation. She shares her ugly parts and her confused and frantic thoughts. Very soon after her husband's death, she questions how soon she can date again and gathers the opinions of her friends and relatives on the idea of her remarrying. She undoubtedly loved her husband very much, but she also refuses play the role of mourning widow forever. Her main objective in the telling of the interactions and thoughts like this one is to remind the reader that, "...[We] are not alone in the experience of death or widowhood or pain."
Miriam Sagan's family and friends play a large role in her story of recovery from loss and the rebuilding of her shaken life. She and her daughter jet off to Korea to stay with her best-friend Kath, who helps her simply by providing an exotic escape for her and allow her to fulfill her "first act as a grief-stricken widow" and start traveling more. There is an endless stream of visits and interactions in the months after her husband's death from a wide variety of unconventional friends including Buddhist monks, her husband's students, ex-lovers (including the man she eventually marries), bodybuilders, artists and writers. She speaks of each one as an integral part of the chain that leads her to a greater understanding of herself, of what death means and how, as individuals, we experience it.
I am not a widow, but my mother is. As a child of a widow, this book helped me understand what it is that someone who has lost a partner goes through. As a person who has known death, like so many of us, it helped me to confront my feelings on the topic in a way that is not necessarily accepted in the context of our American polite society, including the humor that can be found in what is considered the most tragic of situations. Searching for a Mustard Seed is a book this reviewer recommends to everyone, not just widows or even women, but anyone who enjoys well-written, interesting stories of other peoples' lives and experiences.
return to top
Grief Denied: A Vietnam Widow's Story
A Compelling Story of Healing
(reprinted with permission from Pauline Laurent)
SANTA ROSA, CA - Pauline Laurent's path dramatically illustrates the Vietnam era. Born and raised in the Midwest, she met her husband Howard Querry when she was 19. On May 10, 1968, after they were married less than a year, Howard was killed in action in the jungles of Vietnam. Laurent was 22 years old and seven months pregnant when her husband's body was escorted back to the states with the instructions, Nonviewable.
Pauline Laurent took 30 years to reconcile the death of her husband in the Vietnam War. Grief Denied - A Vietnam Widow's Story is Laurent's moving and inspiring tale of how her healing finally occurred, and how she reclaimed her life when she faced and walked through her grief.
The book was released by Catalyst For Change, Santa Rosa, CA on Veterans Day, November 11, 1999. There are an estimated 18,000 Vietnam widows. An estimated 20,000 children were left fatherless by the war. All Americans were touched by that war, whether they fought in the jungles of Vietnam, resisted in the streets of American cities or simply watched the war on television.
Pauline Laurent's book presents an insider's view of the private world of the many people personally devastated by the Vietnam War. She makes poignantly clear the price we pay when we hide, deny or delay grief. Yet, following her process and her discoveries about life, loss, and healing inspires us and allows each of us the possibility of healing, too. Judy Tatelbaum, MSW, author of The Courage to Grieve.
Grief Denied is about raising a daughter without a father,and about living with the shame of having lost the girl's father in a very unpopular war. It is about the denial, anger, addictions and rage that were the aftermath of Laurent's loss. It's also about the climate in our country, which discourages grieving for anyone who has lost a loved one, especially in the Vietnam War.
Laurent's denial and avoidance led her to escape her pain for many years through overworking, addictive relationships and eventually food. Her geographic escapes took her from the Midwest to Colorado and eventually to California, where for 13 years she sought refuge in Werner Erhard's work. With no resolution still, she continued searching, without relief. She eventually lost her ability to manage her addiction to food and soared to a weight of almost 200 pounds.
When Laurent's daughter, at age 24, announced her wedding plans, Laurent could no longer deny her grief. She began long-term therapy, Twelve-Step recovery work and a spiritual search -- all of which eventually led her to writing Grief Denied.
This book is for everyone who has ever lost someone they love. The cost is $14.95 plus $5.00 postage and handling Shipping is by Priority Mail. (California residents add $1.12 sales tax per book.) Send a check for the total amount to: Catalyst For Change, P.O. Box 5158, Santa Rosa CA 95402.
return to top
Terrorism: The Only Way is Through
A Child's Story
By Rosina G. Schnurr, Ph.D.
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D.
[Order from Amazon.com]
Dedicated to the children who lived through 9-11-2001, Terrorism: The Only Way is Through, A Child's Story, is written by an experienced clinical psychologist who draws from her work with grieving and traumatized children. The concept of the phrase "The only way is through" is illustrated in vignettes of a family struggling with the death of the mother in the events of 9-11-01. Rather than turn away from or hide their strong emotions the family learns that they must face them, experience them and go on, and also that it is OK to have these strong feelings. The story begins with the day of 9-11-2001 and through the voice of a latency-aged child, follows the process of a family as they worry about the mother, realize that she is dead, and attempt to rebuild their lives. The story is well told and covers concepts of grief, posttraumatic stress syndrome, death, and changes in family routines and life in an easy to understand and easy to relate to fashion. The family events and the information they share with each other ring true and clearly describe the process of recovering from grief and trauma. The action demonstrates the concepts and the child narrator serves as a role model for children reading this book. The following passage is an example of one of the ways the experience of grief is communicated.
Grammy said that missing Mom was like standing on the shore of the ocean. The waves were like feelings.
Sometimes they would rush in to shore, knock me down and roll right over me.
I remember playing in the waves when we visited Grammy last summer.
Sometimes the waves were really strong. Jamie and I laughed a lot when we got caught in the waves.
Other times, Grammy said, the waves would be so far away from the shore that I would forget all about them. I decided that when I felt like crying, I would think about those waves. I would just let them wash right over me because I know that soon they would leave and I would feel fine again. (P.47)
The story ends with the child understanding that his mother is with him in spirit. Returning to an earlier event in the story, the family plays a football game against their relatives. By facing their trauma and grief directly they are able to move ahead in their lives.
Also, what Uncle Steve didn't know was that we had a secret player: Mom.
"Do you hear what she's saying?" Dad whispered.
Jamie and I nodded our heads.
Then we all shouted:
"THE ONLY WAY IS THROUGH!!!!"
And we won! (p.50)
This story will be useful for any child who is experiencing loss and grief, and transcends the events of 9-11 in presenting a description of the process of grieving, particularly in the first year of the loss. Parents, caregivers and therapists will find it a useful resource for helping their children and will find some healing messages in the story for themselves as well.
return to top
My Father's Ghost: the Return of My Old Man and Other Second Chances
By Suzy McKee Charnas. Jeremy P. Tarcher/Putnam 2002
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D.
[Order from Amazon.com]
My Fathers Ghost: the Return of My Old Man and Other Second Chances by Suzy McKee Charnas is a wonderfully written memoir of Charnas reunion with the father who abandoned her and her family when she was 8 years old. As she takes care of him in his old age they are afforded an opportunity to establish a new relationship. Charnas writes of the relationship with her father and the difficulty of caring for an aging parent with love, respect and humor. In making use of her fathers journals she creates a living memorial which is just what her father, who wrote that he did not want people to be aware of him while he was alive but did want them to know about him after he died, had wished. Look for a longer review in GriefandRenewal.Com in coming weeks.
return to top
Flash of Life
By Kara L.C. Jones, Kota Press, Vashon Island, Washington, info@kotapress.com
ISBN 1-929 359-01-02, Copyright 1999, Paperback 98 pp.
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D., 9-21-02
[Available through www.kotapress.com or
Order from Amazon.com]
In Flash of Life, Kara Jones, a poet, documents and shares her joys, anxieties and sometimes hilariously frustrating, experiences of her pregnancy, and the subsequent, horror, shock, anger, grief and beginning of healing following her son's Dakota's, still birth. These poems are so good that as a reviewer it is hard to refrain from just quoting as many of them as possible with the least amount of commentary.
Through her evocative poems which draw on the wisdom of Native Americans as well as her personal knowledge and experience, she makes clear what for many has not been clear- that the still birth of a child is the death of a child, the loss of a family member, as heart wrenching, unimaginable, and bitter as the loss of any child. In the forward to the second edition of her book, Jones writes,
The one thing that seems to be coming to the surface for all of us, is fact that we will no longer be closeted with our grief. . . . To explain, I offer this example: When your mother or father dies, are you asked to wipe them off the family tree, remove all their photos, and never mention them again? Then why should parents of stillborn children be asked to do those things after the deaths of their children?
Jones' poems capture both her inner experience and her shared experience with her husband. In the first section she describes shopping trips for underwear, girls' nights out which are no longer quite the same, and her husbands unswerving support. Her poems embrace both the intensely personal and the universal. In one poem she invokes the wisdom of the universe and is comforted by the moon, the night, and the mountains. Mother Mountain and the Great Mother offer her clues to how to manage her fears in the final stanza of "Learn the Basics" (p.25-26):
Child, She says, All you can do
is give birth, love them for
who they are, and find some way
to calm your mind during
the wee hours of the late shift.
And I ask the Great Mother,
What will I do if dont spend my time
worrying? She looks at me with
kindness and patience, answers,
If you can learn to fill your pen
with the Light of the Moon and let
Night be your sheets of paper, then you
will see a lifetime of poems fall
from your hands, putting stars
in the Night sky of the late shift.
But the still birth of Dakota turns this beautiful vision into an incredible challenge, as Jones confronts her shock and anger, her numbness and the difficulties she and her husband experience as they both grieve:
Even my husband has already
written a song about our
dead son, two weeks gone,
and I still think writing out grief
is bullshit. What does it matter?
Nothing matters, nothing is real.
("Anger I", p.46)
As time progresses Jones begins to write and heal, but her struggle continues, as there is no substitute for her son, for the future which she and her husband will not have with him: "Poems are a poor substitute/ for a baby. Only a baby/ is a good substitute for a baby/ and even at that,/ it won't be the same baby/you gave birth to the first time,/ it won't be Dakota . . ." ("Do Not Mistake it for Acceptance", pp. 49-51)
In another poem she describes her experience of dating everything from the time of Dakota's death, an experience many of us who have suffered a loss can immediately recognize. Her husband encourages her to start using a calendar again ("I've Begun to Mark Time", p.62), but in her contact with another parent who has an internet memorial site for still-born children she receives a message, "By the way, our boys/were just one day apart as/ my son was born and died on March 10th" (p. 63), and realizes that she is not alone.
In other poems she captures the numbness, emptiness, anger and beginning of acceptance of her grief, as in "At the Shore" (p.69):
When I wasn't looking
my son became the ocean shore,
he became that sound of rocks,
shuffling around
surfing against one another
clanking like diamonds
being polished from their rough,
he became the ebb and flow
of grief, . . .
Jones ends her book of poetry with a wonderful prose description of a very real, healing dream, which brings her lasting comfort and hope. Through Flash of Life Jones reaches out to us all with her message of shared loss, comfort and hope. And, in case this is not enough, Jones has included a list of resources for the reader at the end of the book, and also has created with her husband both a website and publishing company to help others express their grief and share their path of healing.
return to top
Treasures of Darkness
By Ken Hekman, Writers Club Press, New York 2001, 125 pp.
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D. 10-21-2001
[Order from Amazon.com]
Ken Hekman was living the American dream: great marriage, healthy
teenage children, exciting, successful career, vacations, etc. until one
horrific winter night when the police came to his door with the worst
news a parent can ever hear. His daughter, driving at the speed limit,
seat belt on, with no alcohol or drugs, had hit an invisible spot of
ice, crashed into an oncoming car, and been killed, all in an instant.
Hekman's quest to know how to endure, go on living, and make sense of
such a tragic loss forms the background for the poems and writings that
he shares in his heartfelt Treasures of Darkness. The title of his book
is taken from a quote from the Bible (Isaiah 45:3): "I will give you the
treasures of the darkness, riches stored in secret places, so that you
will know that I am the Lord, the God of Israel, who summons you by
name." Hekman identifies himself as a practicing Christian, from the
outset of his book, and his musings and poems often include thoughts
about God and the religion, as well as his own personal experience of
grief.
Hekman opens his book by stating that "Grief can be a very dangerous
place." But that it also ". . . can bear extraordinary rewards." (p.xi)
He writes, "There is a freedom that comes from facing death head on
unlike any other freedom known to man. There are insights and
perspectives about ourselves, about life, about God, and about
relationships that jump off the page in the book of grief." (p.xi)
His book is divided into four sections which follow the natural path of
healing from grief: experiencing fear of death, experiencing fear of
living,
experiencing a lack of fear of death, experiencing a lack of fear of
living.
In the first section Hekman introduces his family and fortunate
lifestyle, and honestly describes his false sense of safety in the
context of his life.
In the second section he addresses his initial feelings and experiences
in the period immediately following his daughter's death. In one poem he
highlights his new experience of morning, identifying himself as living
in "the shadows now." (p.19) In another poem, Forever Sad, he writes, "I
shall be forever sad/And mourn the loss of love I had, / For though I
try, I cannot hide/ The anguish that I feel inside." (p.27)
The third section of Hekman's book addresses the process of healing. The
first poem of this section points to the need to allow one's feelings
full play in order to heal:
- Tears
- Do not be ashamed of choosing to weep,
For tears are the blood of the soul.
It's sadder by far to see people keep
Their feelings from making them whole. (p.44)
Then next poem on a more personal note begins:
- I Cry to the Sky
- I cry to the sky as the day fades to night,
The hesitant tears finally give up their fight,
Remembering the daughter who drew me outdoors
With hiking and biking and camps by the shores. . . (p.45)
His poems to his daughter are among the most moving and touching of the
poems he writes. In one titled, Forever Seventeen, he writes wistfully,
"Come visit me by dream tonight." and later in the same poem, "Let's
take a walk around the block, /resume our simple idle talk/ of college
plans and marriage hope." (p.47)
In the final section of the book Hekman finds some resolution for his
questions and some peace in his life. He finds a deeper understanding of
God, which involves appreciating the mystery of God without expecting to
be protected from it, and without expecting to understand it fully in
this life.
This section opens with a poem, The Rising Tide, which asserts the
return of balance to life, a balance which now embraces both the
experience of loss and return. For Hekman, the ultimate meaning of his
experience to date is to place him in a new relationship with God, and
with Hekman's own role in life. He concludes that nothing is more
important than "the pursuit of God."
In his afterward Hekman states that he is still grieving but that his
understanding of life has profoundly deepened. He writes, ". . .
Carla's death has taught me that life isn't what I thought it to be.
Life is certainly valuable, but not in the same sense as it once was. I
embrace life, but I would embrace death just as fully if it were to be
in my path. (p.109); and similarly, ". . . I also have a new sense of the
purposes of life. I am not my own. I never have been, although my
confession of this truth has never been more true than it is now . . .
Now I accept each day as a gift of God, and I'm ready to let him have
his way with me, day by day." (p.109)
Hekman is an international health care consultant by profession. His
journey into grief has led him into poetry as well. While his poems are
sometimes not as well crafted as one might wish, they do convey his
emotions and sense of loss in a way that is easily understood. In this
shared journey Hekman's documentation of his path allows us to walk with
him through the dark cavern of grief. Through his journey we gain a
glimpse of a possible resolution to questions raised in grief’s wake,
and a sense of what it might mean to embrace life in its true fullness.
Given the course of the recent national and international events, such
lessons could not be more timely.
return to top
Book Announcement: Beyond Coping-Widows Reinventing Their Lives
I am writing to let you know about a new book recently published by Pear
Press entitled "Beyond Coping - Widows Reinventing Their Lives". The
book is an
anthology of stories collected by Molly Hurd and Margie Macdonald and
written by ordinary women of all ages across Canada who have experienced
the
loss of their spouse. They have been through the process of grieving,
but have gone on to reinvent themselves in some fashion. The process of
reinvention
takes many forms - for some it involves new careers or achievements, for
others it can be as simple as overcoming old fears or taking small steps
towards
independence. These stories describe many struggles, both internal and
external, but the ultimate message is one of inspiration and hope.
For information about ordering and to read reviews and descriptions of
the book, please go to our website at www.pearpress.com.
return to top
Waking to Tears: Losing a Loved One to Violence
Compiled by Traci Bieber Nelson, Writers Club Press, New York 2001, pp.143
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D. 7-27-2001
[Order from Amazon.com]
Waking to Tears: Losing a Loved One to Violence brings into direct focus the
devastating effects of such a loss. Traci Bieber Nelson, who lost both of her
parents to separate violent deaths, has compiled the unedited writings of those
who have lost parents, children, spouses and others through murder. The writings
are incredibly moving and challenging to read in their direct revelation of pain
and anger. They serve her intended purpose to let others who have had such losses
know they are not alone, and to make all of us aware of violence’s terrible cost
to society.
The writings are organized alphabetically by state and author. Some of the writers
have chosen to remain anonymous. The anger, pain, loss, and ongoing void in the
lives of the writers brought about by the senseless, meaningless violence of
others are highlighted throughout the varied essays and poems.
In one essay, “You Should Be Getting On WITH Your Life”, Debra O’Brien writes, “
‘You should be getting on with your life’, says a friend of mine. I am always
amazed by that statement. When people say that to me I want to SCREAM at them, but
I don’t because I realize they do not say it to upset me... What is it they really
want from me? For me to be the same person as I was before my son, Devin, was
murdered? NO that will never happen. Part of me was murdered with him and I will
never be the same. Shot in the head three times is not something you ever ‘get
over’ or ‘forget’! (p.53)”
There are a number of poems and memories in tribute to the people who have been
murdered. Some of the writers also call for a change in the way our society
handles the rights of victims and their families, and for changes in our society’s
seemingly endless tolerance for guns and reckless behaviors. The unfailing love
and continuing connection to those who have died is one of the major themes which
unites all of the writings. The concluding stanza to a poem by Deb in Florida
captures this well, “I will carry you with me/Until my life on earth ends/When we
are together in heaven/Where my heart finally mends. (p.37)”
By making the personal cost of violence clear, Waking to Tears makes an
impassioned, eloquent plea for ending the violence endemic to our society. Bieber
Nelson writes, “We live in a disposable fast paced society. Finding the quick and
easiest way through life. Does this mean we take others lives when we are not
happy? Does this mean we rob, injure and kill someone because we don’t like his or
her beliefs, race, religion, sexuality, opinions or decisions? Does this mean when
we are not happy with ourselves we take our own life or kill others? . . . There is
no clear answer to violence but changes must be made. Violence can strike no
matter where you live, no matter what race, religion, occupation or social status-
violence knows no boundaries.(pp.xi-xii)”
Waking To Tears is vital reading for all who have lost a loved one to violence and
for all who have not.
return to top
Margaret Owen's book, A World of Widows, documents with fact and
anecdote the harrowing existence of millions of widows in developing
countries. Ms. Owen is a lawyer specializing in the legal aspects of women
in developing countries. However, it was not until she became a widow that
she became aware of the significance of the plight of widows in
developing countries. Living in London, she experienced the
difficulties of widowhood that women in Western cultures experience. She
was not aware of the degree to which Western widows are protected by
Western law and human rights protections. She begins her
forward:
"I had been widowed only a few months and was about to leave for the USA to teach a course on 'Women, Law, Development and Health' when a widowed Malawian friend, Miriam, came to stay with me. Almost the first question she asked as she looked around my livingroom, was whether my husband had living brothers. When I told her that he did, her expression changed to astonishment. "You mean that they let you stay in this house and allowed you to keep all these things?"
This story serves as a fitting introduction and foreshadowing of the
information to be revealed in her book. Owen describes with
scholarly detail the humiliating and dangerous rituals Third World widows
undergo which serves as a prelude of a life of poverty, loneliness, and
servitude which will almost inevitably follow. She details the laws and
the tribal and local customs which interact in such a way that widows
remain unprotected from violence of every sort. She discusses the
inheritance laws and customs that serve to disenfranchise the widow and
her children from the entirety of her possessions. Even when the
husband has made an effort through a will, and other actions to protect
his wife and family from being robbed after his death, these efforts are
ignored, sometimes through blatant destruction of records and or simply
through violence and theft. Owen highlights the deleterious effect
of these brutal customs on children. Once a widow is stripped of all her
belongings and deprived of an ability to establish even a meager
income via farming or another simple form of subsistence, she is
unable to afford to send her children to school, as they become much
needed labor. She is also unable to prevent them from being taken by her
in laws, as well as unable to protect them once they have been taken
away.
Refugee widows are also identified
in this book, as representing a special case of widowhood. These
women, having fled their homes in order to survive, are left without any
traditional source of support. They have often been psychologically
brutalized if not physically. Owen calls on refugee aide groups to
develop a more thorough understanding of the needs of these women so that
programs can appropriately support them.
Throughout the book, Owen reports on groups and organizations of widows in
African countries and in India which seek to legally and economically
empower themselves and thus bring about better lives for themselves and
their children, as well as add a very important new voice to the cause of
women's rights and human rights. Owen's own group, Empowering Widows
in Development seeks to provide
advocacy and lobbying on behalf of widows.
A World of Widows is strongly recommended reading
for anyone seeking to broaden their understanding of the status of widows
and of women in the world.
return to top
Healing Grief: Reclaiming Life After Any Loss
by James Van Praagh. Dutton, New York, New York, 2000. pp. 286 ISBN: 0525945407
Reviewed by Laura Slap-Shelton, Psy.D. 11-7-2000 [Order from Amazon.com]
Many people, myself
included, experience odd happenings and events following the death of a
loved one. Lights go on and off for no reason, household items move
around inexplicably, presences of the dead are felt, and sometimes
seen. In my case, on the night of my first husband's death, the music
tape that we always played for our 1 year old daughter
played continuously throughout the night on a tape recorder which did
not have an automatic rewind system, and was found in complete tangles
the next morning. No one in the house that night had the heart or
perhaps the courage to stop it from playing. I did not have a spiritual
frame work with which to process these experiences, although I had had
some other experiences of a similar type. After a number of similar
experiences I finally threw up my hands and admitted that there was a
lot more to life and the universe than I had previously admitted or
understood. My life opened in a new way, and I realized that my
husband's death had indeed been a very unusual type of gift. In my
interviews with other widows I found that others were also struggling
to put together the meaning of these 'supernatural'
encounters.
James Van Praagh's book Healing Grief: Reclaiming Life
After Any Loss, provides the spiritual framework which encompasses
these unusual experiences or encounters with the spirit world. In
Healing Grief Van Praagh combines practical guidelines for coping with
grief with detailed descriptions of communications between the living
and their lost loved ones in order to highlight the rich opportunities
for spiritual growth that losses of all kinds bring. While the
practical guidelines may be found in many good books on coping with
grief, his depictions of the communication between the bereaved and the
person who has died are fascinating and unique. The meaning and
comfort that the people whom he reads for derive from their encounters
with their lost ones are also movingly communicated by both Van Praagh
and in first hand accounts by his clients.
Van Praagh writes
from a spiritual philosophy, which has a basic tenant that, "When the
body is shed and we cross over to the spirit world, we open the door to
eternal life." The experiences we have while on earth are predetermined
lessons chosen before we came to earth. There is essentially no such
thing as death in this philosophy. However, on the human side of
the equation, there is still loss, and loss is a powerful spiritual
teacher.
Van Praagh presents readings with people who have lost
husbands to murder, who have lost husbands after long and beautiful
marriages, with parents who have lost a child, with children who have
or about to loose a parent, and with those who have lost pets.
The details communicated by those in the spirit world are impressive
and in one case even allow the apprehension of a murderer.
The
message that all loss presents an opportunity for spiritual growth was
most movingly written about in the chapter on the death of children, to
this writer's mind, the most difficult type of loss to experience. Van
Praagh allowed the parents to speak in this chapter. One mother writes
of her experience of connecting with her son's spirit: "Those healing
words from our son through James gave Eric and me a sense of calm and
renewal. Our lives were forever changed. We were able to
view what formerly looked like problems as opportunities for
spiritual development. My husband began to approach his medical
practice and all of his life in a more spiritual way. We are now able
to see Ian's passing as a beautiful gift. By learning not to fear
death, we no longer fear life." pp.115.
Van Praagh stresses that
grief is the natural response to loss, and that our emotional responses
to grief are natural and need to be honored and understood so that
growth can occur. He encourages the experiencing and working through of
the emotions of loss and grief, and respects the importance of honestly
processing all of the emotions that arise at the time of loss. At
the end of the book he provides a brief section on reclaiming life
after death and includes some spiritual exercises
and meditations.
Healing Grief will bring comfort and
encouragement to those who are coping with bereavement and to those who
are concerned with spiritual growth and the experience of loss.
Although it may not suit the hard core 'non-believer', most others will
be well served by its healthy balance of earthly self-care and
spiritual awareness.
return to top
return to recent reviews
return to articles main page
|